They're Real! - Maskara za produljenje i volumen

Reformulation - Major Downgrade

I WORSHIPPED this mascara for 12+ years. It was my ride or die, and I would’ve never switched it out. However, the reformulation ruined this mascara, and I’ve had to swap for Hourglass. It breaks my heart, but I can no longer repurchase until Benefit reverts.

Great 👍

Been using this mascara for 15 years or so. I've tried many others. This remains my go to, to date. Not waterproof.. sometimes it gets on my upper eyelid because my lashes are so long, but I refuse to use waterproof mascara, so that's on me.

New formula is horrible!

My all time favorite mascara is now garbage! This would smudge under any conditions: hot yoga, ranching, river work, and even sleeping in a hot room. Now it smudges instantly. Big dark smudges under my eyes and I only papplu to my upper lashes. I’m so sad! I think I’ve been using this for more than 15 years. Please bring back the old formula.

Flakes & Smears

Applied in the morning for work and by early afternoon was flaking and smearing. Kept needing to wipe my eyelids and under eyes. After a month the formula starts to clump when applied to eyelashes. Will not purchase again.

Great brush but formula smudges

I love the brush and the consistency of the formula but I think they changed the formula because it smudges almost immediately, particularly on my brow bone. This didn’t used to happen when I used the product in the past so I don’t think I’ll be repurchasing.

BRING BACK THE OLD FORMULA!

I was faithful to this mascara for years, and then they changed the formula. It smudges, and flakes badly. I was shocked to see that after a few hours of wear, I looked like Alice Cooper! in in

Looks incredible when first applied but after an hour or 2 it’s all over my eyelids and under eyes. I don’t know if they changed the formula or what because this used to be great but unfortunately it just doesn’t last.

Better than that Colossal Crap!!!

A tried and true staple. When this first launched, it flaked ALOT! I believe they reformulated and it no longer flakes. I like that it adds some length and volume. Especially when I don’t feel like putting on falsies. The wand is sturdy and easy to use.

Reformulated and gives clumpy smudges

Not sure what happened to this mascara. So disappointing, it was my absolute favourite. Currently using and it’s such a dry, clumpy, smudgy nightmare! Skip, it’s been reformulated and doesn’t compare to what it used to be

Long and separated lashes

Used this for years and would always repurchase. Great mascara. Makes lashes lovely and long and separated

Skip this one

This product definitely lengthens and darkens your eyelashes. However, I’ve worn this product 3 times and each time, I end up with raccoons eyes. All the product ends up anywhere but my eyelashes at the end of the day. I will be returning this unfortunately.

This used to be my holy grail product. after years of repurchasing it never failed me. they must have changed the formula because it is so dry. it clumps up and takes twice as long for me to do mascara. I just bought this tube not long ago and it’s already dried out.